I won’t be able to see Up until it comes out on DVD because I’m not going to commit suicide by popcorn going to a movie theater.
Why are so many mommybloggers saying a scene about miscarriage / ectopic pregnancy (more likely) is inappropriate for kids? I grew up knowing about miscarriage and stillbirth. It prepared me better than many in the blogosphere to deal with infertility – no matter how much I seem to rail.
This unwillingness to expose children to death, grief, and all it encompasses tells me a lot about parenting styles today. Trying to protect your children from reality never serves them well as they grow into adulthood. They will find themselves blindsided by events they are unprepared for.
The reviews that say how inappropriate this is for children just scream that infertility and miscarriage/stillbirth must be swept under the rug never to be seen or spoken of. Guess what? They are real and they happen. They happen a lot more than most people are comfortable talking about.
I have role models most people don’t. I get that. There are days I believe my family is from Mars. They are just from Appalachia – and not, for the most part, radical right wing religious nuts. I read people talking about how hard it is to talk about death to their kids and remember my adult relatives arguing over reincarnation, heaven, and nothingness. I also remember them arguing over who got to be buried in which cemetery plot in the family cemetery. I never realized how different that was before now.
I grew up knowing that my female relatives had had miscarriages and stillbirths and pregnancy does not mean a baby is coming. It is such a disservice to today’s children when we aren’t honest about it. And, there are age appropriate ways to be honest.
Pretending infertility and miscarriage doesn’t exist just feeds into the hatred that many feel towards those who suffer from this disease. And, make no mistake, there is a hatred that is almost palpable from some sectors of society. A sort of, “how dare you have that problem and expect us to respect you in any way.”
Think about it. Think hard. What is the real reason you don’t want your child to know about infertility or miscarriage? It says more about you and your own insecurities, prejudices, and values than you think. What it says is not very complimentary.
ETA: No one with common sense takes a child under about 8 to a PG movie, preferably 10. At least, that is how the MPAA people think about that rating.